Information on the Sweet v. Cardona Settlement

Be aware that there may be scammers contacting you regarding the Sweet v. Cardona lawsuit and settlement. As the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) says: Don’t pay anybody for anything related to your borrower defense claim. Nobody can move you up in line, give you special access, or guarantee a successful application. Not for free, and certainly not for money. And only scammers will ask. And if you spot a scam, tell the FTC: ReportFraud.ftc.gov. Visit the FTC’s website for more information.

The Latest on the Settlement in Sweet v. Cardona

UPDATE: On April 13, 2023, the Supreme Court denied intervenors’ petition attempting to stop settlement relief. Attempts to delay settlement by the three schools have now been denied three times, by Federal District Court Judge William Alsup, by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, and by the Supreme Court. Accordingly, the Department of Education may continue to discharge loans under the terms of the approved settlement. View the press release here

The institutions are continuing to pursue their appeal in the Ninth Circuit. We will update this page with further information as that appeal develops. 

For the most accurate and up-to-date information about the Sweet case, please check back here and follow us on Twitter @EdDebtJustice for the latest case updates. 

Upcoming Dates

For the automatic relief group:

January 28, 2024: You should receive your full settlement relief on or before this date.

For the decision group:

July 28, 2023: If you submitted your BD application on or before December 31, 2017, you should receive a decision by this date. Please note that the Department of Education has one year from the date of decision to effectuate full relief.

January 28, 2024: If you submitted your BD application between January 1, 2018, and December 31, 2018, you should receive a decision by this date. Please note that the Department of Education has one year from the date of decision to effectuate full relief.

Link

Top Sweet Settlement Questions

My servicer is notifying me that the COVID payment pause is ending soon. Will I have to pay my loans while I wait for my discharge or decision? 

No. 

The Department will hold Class Members in forbearance or stopped collection status, and will reimburse you for any accrual of interest, until you receive your settlement relief or, where applicable for members of the decision group, until a decision denying settlement relief becomes final. For Direct Loans, this should happen automatically; for commercially held FFEL loans, you may have to notify your lender that you are eligible for an administrative forbearance based on borrower defense. 

If you are a Post-Class Applicant or if you applied for borrower defense after November 16, 2022, you can still ask your servicer to place your loans in borrower defense forbearance until you receive a decision. However, like with other types of forbearance, interest will still accrue on your loans while your BD application is pending. Whether you receive a refund of that interest upon resolution of your borrower defense application will depend on the applicable regulations. 

Please note that while servicers should know about Sweet relief and about borrower defense forbearance, sometimes servicer representatives do not have the appropriate or accurate information. If this happens, reach out to your servicer’s ombudsman’s office or the Department of Education’s ombudsman’s office. Regardless of what your servicer says, if you did receive a notice from the Department about this settlement, that is the most accurate statement regarding your Sweet relief. 

I'm a Sweet Class Member and I recently received a notice stating that my borrower defense application had been approved in relation to Vara v. Cardona (as opposed to Sweet v. Cardona). What does this mean?

I'm a Sweet Class Member but I know the COVID payment pause is scheduled to end soon. Will the resumption of federal student loan payments impact me? 

The dropdown menu to the right provides instructions for Sweet Class Members and Post-Class Applicants who have not yet received the communication they were expecting from the Department of Education.

Please carefully review the following before filling out the survey below:

I’m a Sweet Class Member in the automatic relief group, but I have not yet received relief, or I have received less relief (fewer loans discharged or less money refunded) than I was expecting. What can I do? 

The Department of Education has confirmed that emails referencing Vara v. Cardona were sent out in error. If you received such a notice you may treat it as notice of your inclusion in the Sweet settlement. 

No, if you are a Sweet class member you do not need to resume payments on any loans that are covered by the settlement. Class members (and all borrower defense applicants) are entitled to keep their loans related to their BD application(s) in administrative forbearance until they receive their discharge or decision on their application(s), whichever is applicable. Administrative forbearance does not apply to any federal student loans that you did not apply for borrower defense in relation to nor does it apply to privately held student loans.  

We are aware that some servicers are notifying borrowers about the end of the COVID payment pause even though their loans are in administrative forbearance. If your servicer is telling you that you will have to resume payments, we recommend contacting the servicer directly and telling them that you are a Sweet class member in borrower defense (administrative) forbearance. If you have difficulties with your servicer, you can contact the Federal Student Aid's Office of the Ombudsman here.

All federal loan servicers have until January 28, 2024, to effectuate settlement relief for Class Members in the automatic relief group.  

While we cannot confirm whether the amount you expect to be refunded is accurate, historically the Department of Education has sometimes disbursed refunds incrementally, via multiple different checks.  

For those in the automatic relief group, the Department of Education has until January 28, 2024, to disburse refunds of any amounts you previously paid to the federal government toward the loans for which you applied for borrower defense and are receiving Sweet settlement relief.  

We are unable to answer individual questions about refund amounts owed to Class Members. If you still have not received the settlement relief that you believe you are eligible for by January 28, 2024, please let us know by submitting our “Get Help” form

Am I a Sweet class member? 

The settlement defines the class as “all individuals who had a borrower defense application pending as of June 22, 2022.” Additionally, under the settlement, the Department of Education agreed to rescind all borrower defense denials that it issued between December 2019 and October 2020. If you received a form denial notice during that time period, the Department will treat your original application as if it had never been denied and you will be a member of the class. 

The settlement divides the class—all individuals who had a borrower defense application pending as of June 22, 2022—into two groups.   

The first group is the automatic relief group. You are a member of this group if you are a Class Member who submitted a borrower defense application relating to a school or schools on this list (often referred to as the “Exhibit C” list). If you are in this group, then on or before January 28, 2024, you will have the outstanding loans that were the subject of your application fully discharged, will receive refunds of any amounts you previously paid to the federal government toward those loans, and will have the credit tradeline associated with those loans deleted from your credit report (“Full Settlement Relief”). 

The second group is the decision group. You are a member of this group if you are a Class Member who submitted a borrower defense application relating to a school or schools that are not on the Exhibit C list. If you are in the decision group, you will receive an individual decision on your entitlement to settlement relief according to a set timeline (see “What happens next for Class Members?” below). 

If the Department fails to issue a decision within the timeline, you will receive Full Settlement Relief. 

The Department will use a “streamlined” procedure to evaluate applications of Class Members in the decision group. This means that the Department will accept all allegations in the application as true; will not require further supporting evidence; will not require proof of reliance; and will not apply any statute of limitations. 

If you are in the decision group and you are determined to be eligible for relief, you will receive Full Settlement Relief (the same benefits as members of the automatic relief group). You will receive this relief within one year of the date you receive your approval decision.  

If you are in the decision group and the Department determines that your application does not meet the standards for approval under the streamlined procedures, you will receive a “revise and resubmit” notice. This notice will explain why your application was not approved and provide examples of successful applications. You will have six months from receipt of this notice to submit a revised borrower defense application to the Department. If you submit a revised application, the Department will have six months to either grant relief or issue a final denial notice. If you choose not to resubmit, your notice will convert to a final denial upon the expiration of the six-month resubmission window. If your application is denied, you have the right to challenge that denial in federal court.  

What will happen to my borrower defense application under the settlement? 

What if I applied for borrower defense after June 22, 2022 but before November 16, 2022? 

If you applied for borrower defense after June 22, 2022, but before November 16, 2022 (the date of final approval of the settlement), then you are not a member of the class as defined in the settlement agreement. Instead, you are a “Post-Class Applicant.” 

The settlement provides certain benefits to Post-Class Applicants. Under the settlement, Post-Class Applicants will receive decisions on their applications by January 28, 2026. If the Department fails to provide any Post-Class Applicant with a decision during that time period, then they will receive Full Settlement Relief (the same relief as if they were a Class Member in the decision group who did not receive a timely decision). 

Post-Class Applicants will receive individual decisions on their applications regardless of whether they borrowed to attend a school on the Exhibit C list. In other words, even if you attended a school on the list, you will not receive automatic relief if you applied for borrower defense after June 22, 2022, but before November 16, 2022. Post-Class Applicants also will not have their applications reviewed under the “streamlined” procedures applicable to Class Members in the decision group. 

Borrowers who applied as Post-Class Applicants will have the credit tradelines for their discharged loans deleted from their credit reports if their borrower defense applications are approved. Post-Class Applicants will not automatically get refunds if their applications are approved, but they might get refunds depending on their individual circumstances. In general, the Department of Education applies a statute of limitations to decide whether a successful borrower defense applicant will get a refund along with discharge. The Department agreed that the limitations period would not apply to Class Members, but it will apply to Post-Class Applicants. Whether a Post-Class Applicant gets a refund will therefore depend on the facts in their application. 

What happens next for Class Members and Post-Class Applicants? When will I receive my relief?

Here is a timeline of important upcoming events for Class Members and Post-Class Applicants:  

For the automatic relief group: 

April 28, 2023: You should have received notice from the Department about your settlement relief on or before this date. If you are a Sweet Class Member in the automatic relief group and have not yet received notice from the Department of Education (ED) about your settlement relief or confirming your post-class status (as applicable), we want to raise this with ED. Please send us an email including the information outlined in response to the first FAQ on this webpage. 

January 28, 2024: You should receive your full settlement relief on or before this date.  

For the decision group: 

May 28, 2023: If you received a form denial notice between December 2019 and October 2020, you should have received a written notice by this date to confirm that your denial has been rescinded and your application is back under consideration. If you are a Sweet Class Member in the decision group and received a form denial notice between December 2019 and October 2020 but have not yet received a written notice confirming that your denial has been rescinded and your application is back under consideration, we want to hear from you. Please send us an email including the information outlined in response to the first FAQ on this webpage. 

 July 28, 2023: If you submitted your BD application on or before December 31, 2017, you should receive a decision by this date. 

January 28, 2024: If you submitted your BD application between January 1, 2018, and December 31, 2018, you should receive a decision by this date. 

July 28, 2024: If you submitted your BD application between January 1, 2019, and December 31, 2019, you should receive a decision by this date. 

January 28, 2025: If you submitted your BD application between January 1, 2020, and December 31, 2020, you should receive a decision by this date. 

July 28, 2025: If you submitted your BD application between January 1, 2021, and June 22, 2022, you should receive a decision by this date. 

If your application is granted, then within one year after you receive the decision, you should receive your full settlement relief. 

For Post-Class Applicants: 

May 28, 2023: You should receive notice from the Department confirming your status as a Post-Class Applicant on or before this date. If you are a Post-Class Applicant and have not yet received notice from the Department of Education (ED) about your settlement relief or confirming your post-class status (as applicable), we want to raise this with ED. Please send us an email including the information outlined in response to the first FAQ on this webpage. 

January 28, 2026: You should receive a decision on your application by this date. 

If you believe you should have received notice, a decision, or relief by one of these dates but did not, please tell us via an email including the information outlined in response to the first FAQ on this webpage.

What if I applied for borrower defense after November 16, 2022?

If you applied for borrower defense after November 16, 2022, then you are not affected by the Sweet settlement. Your application will be decided by the Department according to the applicable regulations. 

I am a Sweet Class Member and I have different types of loans, how does that affect my settlement relief? What kind of refund will I get? 

If you receive Full Settlement Relief under any of the settlement provisions described above, then the Department will cancel all remaining balances on the federal student loans that were the subject of your borrower defense application(s). Cancellation of outstanding loans and deletion of credit tradeline associated with these loans will happen regardless of what type of loan you have. 

However, whether you receive a REFUND of payments made, and in what amount, will differ depending on the type of loans you have. See below for which types of payments will be refunded. 

I went to more than one school on Exhibit C, but only applied for borrower defense for one of them. Will I get Sweet relief for all the schools I attended on Exhibit C? 

No, to receive Sweet relief, you must have submitted a borrower defense application for each school for which you were requesting a discharge.  

Can I still apply for borrower defense?

Yes! If your school misled you, violated state laws, or engaged in other misconduct that affected your decision to borrow federal student loans, you can still apply for borrower defense. However, if you apply for borrower defense now (any time after November 16, 2022), no aspect of the settlement will affect your application. Borrowers can apply for borrower defense here. For an informational guide on applying for borrower defense, click here. 

You can apply for borrower defense even if you are currently enrolled in the school you would be applying for. Borrower defense can apply to any federal student loan that has already been disbursed. 

I previously consolidated my student loans. Will I still get settlement relief?

If you previously consolidated your federal student loans into a Direct Consolidation Loan or a FFEL Consolidation Loan (which allow you to combine multiple federal loans into one), then you will still get the settlement relief to which you would otherwise be entitled if you hadn’t consolidated. You can see whether you have a Direct Consolidation Loan or FFEL Consolidation Loan by logging into your account with Federal Student Aid or your federal loan servicer. 

If you consolidated loans from more than one school into a Direct Consolidation Loan or FFEL Consolidation Loan, and your borrower defense application relates to only one (or less than all) of those schools, then any settlement relief you receive will apply to the portion of your consolidation loan that relates to the school(s) named in your borrower defense application(s). The Department of Education should have data that will allow them to determine what part of your consolidation loan is connected to the school(s) for which you applied for borrower defense and are receiving settlement relief.  

If you previously consolidated your federal student loans into a private consolidation loan – for example, with a lender such as SoFi, Earnest, or CommonBond – then unfortunately, that loan will not be eligible for Sweet settlement relief. The Department of Education does not have the legal authority to discharge loans that are currently held by a private lender, even if those loans were originated as federal loans. You will not get a refund on the amount you refinanced into a private loan, and you will still have to pay your private lender. 

I’m a Sweet Class Member awaiting settlement relief and I’m wondering:

I’m a Sweet Class Member and I’ve received all the relief I’m owed but I’m still wondering:

Additional Settlement and Class Membership Information